Metal Roofing vs. Synthetic Roofing

Metal Roofing vs. Synthetic Roofing: A Comprehensive Comparison

Metal Roofing vs. Synthetic Roofing Hingham massachusetts 15 May

When planning your next roofing project, you may wonder what the difference is between metal roofing and synthetic roofing. Synthetic roofing uses materials created from man-made compounds rather than natural materials such as clay or wood. Rubber roof (EPDM) and plastic polymer roofing are both examples of synthetic roofing.

Sometimes people refer to synthetic roofing and composite roofing as the same thing, but they do have differences. Composite roofing comprises materials that blend many different materials of both synthetic and natural origin. But because composite roofing is technically man-made, it’s often considered synthetic.

Asphalt shingles are considered to be composite roofing materials because they comprise a fiberglass mat, asphalt, and mineral granules.

Homeowners who want a blend of durability and aesthetic appeal will often lean towards synthetic roofing. But another long-lasting and cost-effective roofing solution is metal roofing in Massachusetts.

Durability of Metal vs. Synthetic Roofing

Synthetic roofs such as rubber have exceptional resistance to heat, weather, and UV radiation, but they don’t have a long life (20 years or so). This short life expectancy is due to greater thermal expansion and lower tensile strength, which leads to stress over time.

Conversely, metal roofing can last 70 years or more thanks to its high tensile strength and resistance to wind, fire, and hail.

Cost Comparison: Metal Roofing vs. Synthetic Roofing

You have to consider both the initial price of each material and the long-term cost of maintenance and replacement. Metal roofing costs more upfront compared with synthetic roofing, but doesn’t need as much maintenance and comes with a longer lifespan.

When it comes to ROI, many factors can make metal roofing a better option:

  • Longevity: Metal roofs last two to three times longer than synthetic roofing materials.
  • Durability: Metal roofs are the strongest you can buy.
  • Energy Efficiency: Because they reflect heat away from the home, metal can reduce cooling costs by 40 percent.
  • Home Value: Metal roofs can boost resale value by up to six percent thanks to their longevity, durability, and energy efficiency.
  • Insurance Benefits: Enjoy reduced homeowners' insurance premiums by 35 percent with a metal roof.

Aesthetic Appeal

Both metal and synthetic roofs can enhance a wide range of architectural styles.

  • Metal roofing is available in many styles and colors. Those made out of copper will develop a patina over time, for instance.
  • Synthetic roofing comes in lots of colors, including those that mimic the variations found in tile, wood, and slate.


Synthetic roofing may be the best choice for those who want durable materials with a lower cost and live in a moderate climate. Metal roofing may be best for those who want a higher ROI, who are eco-conscious, and who live in harsh weather conditions.

Book a Consultation With Revered Roofing on the South Shore

Need help deciding between the two? Call our skilled roofers in Mashpee now at 781-536-4589 for a free consultation and quote.

Visit our website: Revered Roofing

We serve the entire South Shore and lower Cape with quality metal roofing products; standing seam, metal shingle and metal panel roofs in Hanson, Taunton, Marshfield, Quincy, Needham, Medfield, Milton, Halifax, Hanover, Falmouth and Plymouth.

Paul installed metal shingles and metal standing seam at my house. Paul and his team did a great job and were a pleasure to deal with. I am a former building official and Paul’s work passed my inspection. I highly recommend Revered Metal Roofing. Mike T.
Contact Revered Metal Roofing

for the guaranteed best price.